Is Value Investing Dead or Still Breathing Fire? A Tactical Investor’s Lens
Nov 17, 2025
The Question Everyone Asks When They Should Be Asking Something Else
Every few years, someone declares value investing dead. It is a ritual as old as the markets themselves. The irony is that these death certificates always appear at the precise moment value begins its next renaissance. When a strategy is hated, mocked, or dismissed, savvy minds lean closer. Extremes signal opportunity. And crowd certainty is usually a contrarian buy signal in disguise.
Value investing is not dead. It is misused, misunderstood, and often practised with the precision of a burro wandering through a minefield. The strategy’s failures come not from its principles but from investors who mistake cheap for valuable and low multiples for hidden treasure.
Templeton hunted at peak pessimism. Benjamin Franklin preached intrinsic worth long before the term existed. Paul Tudor Jones rode waves but kept one eye on the fundamentals. When you study these figures, you realise the same truth: value investing does not die. It adapts. What dies is the lazy application of it.
The Real Debate: Value Investing or Value Traps?
Why “Cheap” Is Often Just “Rotting with a Discount Sticker”
Value investing fails only when investors chase numbers without context. A low P/E ratio is not a value. It is a warning siren. Some businesses trade below book value because they deserve to. Deteriorating assets, dying business models, predatory debt structures. These are not bargains. They are traps.
This is where mass psychology and technical analysis sharpen the blade. You identify not just cheap stocks but inflexion points.
Example: CALM
From mid-2016 to mid-2017, CALM was bleeding lower. Fundamentals looked cheap. The herd avoided it. But technicals flashed something more substantial: exhaustion in selling pressure. A bottom forming. Oversold ranges telling us sentiment had gone too far. Anyone who bought around July 2017 sits on strong long-term gains today.
The lesson: value is not visible in isolation. Value emerges when fundamentals, psychology, and structure align.
The Dynamic Nature of Value
Why the Strategy Stagnates Only When the Practitioner Does: Templeton found bargains across continents long before global screens existed. Fisher hunted for qualitative value in management, culture, and vision. Jones read sentiment shifts before algorithms mapped them. These men expanded value beyond ratios. They treated it as a dynamic discipline requiring patience, timing, and psychological clarity.
Today’s markets demand the same evolution. Value investors cannot cling to static book-to-price screens while the world moves at light speed. They must blend behavioural signals with structural ones. They must question the crowd and study the tape. Value does not reward those who wait. It rewards those who wait in the right places.
Market Crises: Where Value Investing Shows Its Teeth
When Fear Takes the Wheel, Value Investors Take the Assets: Value investing shines brightest when markets break. Crises strip illusions from prices and reveal intrinsic worth.
The Dot-Com Collapse
Buffett avoided tech stocks not because he lacked imagination but because valuations detached from reality. When the bubble burst, Berkshire rose while the S&P imploded.
S&P 500 (2000–2002): –37.6%
Berkshire: +26.4%
That is not luck. That is discipline.
The 2008 Meltdown
Buffett deployed capital into Goldman Sachs, GE, and later Bank of America—companies drowning in panic selling but structurally sound. Those trades generated billions once markets stabilised.
COVID-19 Crash (2020)
The market fell by thirty-four per cent in weeks—panic suffocated reason. Meanwhile, value-driven managers like Seth Klarman accumulated positions in companies with strong fundamentals and temporary dislocation. These examples show a consistent pattern. Crisis creates mispricing. Value investors who keep calm extract treasure while the crowd drowns in fear.
Principles That Keep Value Investing Alive
Why the Strategy Outlives Every Market Cycle:
Margin of Safety:
Graham called it a mathematical cushion, but seasoned investors know it is also psychological armour. Buying well below intrinsic value protects you not only from volatility but from your own impulses. When the market convulses, fear distorts perception. The margin of safety gives you something solid to stand on while others run. It is a buffer against panic, a shield against herd contagion, and a structural advantage that compounds silently over time.
Focus on Fundamentals:
Value investing forces you to examine a company’s bones rather than its costumes. Balance sheets, cash flows, competitive moats, and management quality decide survival during crises. Trends come and go. Narratives burn bright and vanish. Fundamentals persist. Companies like Costco, Johnson and Johnson, and Caterpillar survived multiple recessions because their structures were sound. In every crash, traders chase stories. Value investors chase strength. That difference decides who holds assets after the dust settles.
Contrarian Discipline:
True contrarianism is not doing the opposite of the crowd for the sake of theatrics. It is recognising when the crowd has detached from reality. Fear exaggerates risk. Euphoria erases it. Value investors step in when panic magnifies discounts beyond what logic dictates. They exit when collective arrogance inflates prices beyond sense. This discipline is psychological violence against instinct. The mind wants comfort. The strategy demands confrontation.
Patience:
Patience is the only advantage money cannot buy. It is also the one most traders refuse to cultivate. Markets reward those who let time do the compounding, not those who chase every gust of momentum. In crises, opportunities appear rapidly but take years to mature. The best-value trades of the last century occurred when investors held through ridicule. Patience separates the ones who trade noise from those who accumulate power.
Statistical Evidence That Outlives Opinions:
Fama and French found that value outperformed growth by 4.8 per cent annually over twenty-six years. That is not a rounding error. It is structural dominance. Bank of America showed that value beat growth 60% of the time across rolling five-year periods since 1926. Across wars, recessions, depressions, bubbles, and pandemics, value persists.
Numbers track truth.
Crowds track emotions.
Markets have always followed the same arc. Noise rises. Fear distorts. Euphoria blinds. Then reality returns. When it does, value stands exactly where it always stands, waiting for those disciplined enough to find it and patient enough to claim it.
The Role of Mass Psychology
Why Market Irrationality Is the Value Investor’s Fuel: Mass psychology is not an accessory to value investing. It is the engine. Markets misprice assets because humans misprice risk. Fear exaggerates danger. Euphoria erases it. This is Le Bon’s crowd theory in motion. And every crash proves the same principle: crowds destroy value before rational minds reclaim it.
The value investor’s edge is simple. They wait for the crowd to lose its mind, then buy what the crowd abandons. The trick is knowing which assets are wounded and which are dying. That distinction requires discipline, research, and the ability to resist emotional infection.
Is Value Investing Dead? Wrong Question.
The Real Question Is Whether the Investor Has Evolved: Value investing survives every cycle because it is rooted in behaviour, not fashion. Markets will always overshoot. Crowds will always panic. Fear and greed will always distort prices.
The real threat is not the strategy dying.
The real threat is investors who refuse to evolve with it.
Value investing is not buying cheap stocks. It is buying mispriced truth. It is recognising intrinsic worth when the market is blind. It is understanding psychology, timing, and structural strength.
If value appears dead, it is only because the practitioner forgot how to look.
Value Investing Thrives When Others Abandon It
The Strategy Lives in the Space Between Fear and Clarity
Markets move in waves. Strategies rise and fall in popularity. But value endures because inefficiency endures. Irrationality endures. Human emotion endures.
The greatest returns of the next decade will belong to those who blend:
- fundamental strength
- behavioural insight
- technical clarity
- and contrarian resolve
Value investing is not a relic. It is a weapon. A patient one. A sharp one. And in the hands of someone who understands mass psychology, it becomes devastatingly effective.
When the crowd declares value dead, remember:
The grave they are pointing at is usually their own.
Intellect Snacks for the Uncomfortable Truths Crowd
