Beware of all enterprises that require a new set of clothes.
Henry David Thoreau
Current Fed Interest Rate Stance Akin To Nonsense
Remember over a year ago when the Fed raised rates for the 1st time in over a decade: they huffed and puffed warning everyone that they would raise rates several times in 2016 and viola nothing happened until now. Now they are repeating the same thing all over again. To illustrate how bad this economy take into consideration that the Fed has raised rates only twice in the last decade; the economy was a lot stronger in 2006 and 2007 than it is today. Yellen’s statement below illustrates how the Fed is positioning itself so that it can pull another “oops we were wrong once again” moment.
“All the (Federal Open Market Committee) participants recognize that there is considerable uncertainty about how economic policies may change and what effect they may have on the economy,” Yellen said
Has anything changed since the last hike; is the economy stronger? The only thing that is getting stronger is the illusion that this economy is on the mend. If the economy was improving, then a rising rate environment could be seen through a bullish lens. In this instance, this economic recovery is a joke; it is all an illusion that is funded by debt. If the supply of hot money is cut, the markets will tank. The real estate sector is not stable yet, and most people already can’t afford a house, so raising rates is a recipe for disaster.
Our take is that the Fed has raised rates to give them more room to manoeuvre while making it appear that they are loath to embrace negative rates. The Fed has to play a delicate balancing game; the US dollar has to look attractive to the world, as that is what gives the Fed the power to create unlimited money. The US dollar is the World’s reserve currency. If it were not, then the US would have followed Greece’s path long ago.
Current Fed Interest Rate Stance: Fed the Rich at the expense of the poor
It is our ability to rob the world by creating money out of thin air at other nation’s expense that gives the US capacity to hold onto the top dog position precariously. It is precarious because it is just a matter of time before China displaces the US. On a purchasing power parity basis, China has already replaced the US as the World’s largest economy. One day the world will realise that the emperor is naked, fat, old and ugly as sin. However, as there is still some time before this comes into play, we are not going to address this issue.
We believe that the Fed will have no option but to eventually embrace negative rates unless they are looking to trigger a crash. The Fed is famous for artificially creating every boom and bust cycle since the US went off the Gold standard. While it might appear that we are in a bubble-like phase as far as the stock market is concerned, one needs to remember that the masses have not benefitted much from the current rally. History illustrates that the Fed usually pops the bubble after the masses have fully embraced the market.
Markets only crash when the crowd is ecstatic
Additionally, the masses are not euphoric; however, they are turning more bullish, which suggests as we alluded in this article Stock Market Bulls-Stock Market fools-Market Crash next or is this just an Illusion, that it would not surprise us if the markets experienced a decent correction next year. In the interim, we think the Fed’s current move is just a trick to make it appear to the world that our economy is healthy. Now the Fed can lower rates twice before they move to zero, but it will force the rest of the world to lower their rates even more; effectively still making the US dollar the most attractive currency.
The bond market which many have given up for dead are looking for an excuse to rally sharply. We will look at this in more detail in a follow-up article. However, if you look at the long-term chart below, it is easy to spot that bonds have not crashed. They were pushed to extreme levels as individuals continued to embrace bonds for years despite the miserable returns they offered due to the safety factor.
The masses are still nervous
The masses, in general, were sceptical of this bull market and bought the hype that it was going to fall apart tomorrow for the past nine years. After Trump won money started moving out of bonds and into the market. What we have is a simple rotation; money is moving from one market into another. Now bonds are extremely oversold, and the markets are trading close to the extremely overbought ranges. When the markets start to pull back money will flow into bonds pushing rates lower. At that point, one will be able to tell if the rally in bonds is just a dead cat’s bounce or if the bull is ready to run again.
This is a weekly chart containing five years worth of data (each bar represents one week’s worth of data); it is easy to spot that the Bond market is extremely oversold. Trump’s win has created a lot of enthusiasm, and a large number of individuals who were sitting on the sidelines moved out of bonds and into the market. As the current upward move has been incredibly powerful, it is likely that bonds could experience a counter move that is equally strong.
For the first in time in roughly 24 months, bullish sentiment has soared to the 50% mark twice over a period of 6 weeks. Up until now, the masses were constantly negative, even though the markets continued to trend higher. Things are different right now; while the sentiment is not in the Euphoric, the percentage change is quite significant and signifies that some bloodletting is in order. Bonds are attempting to find support in the 148.00 ranges; a weekly close below this level should result in a test of the 142.00-144.00 ranges, with a possible overshoot to the 140 ranges. The downside risk for bonds now is limited.
The markets have been resilient to sharp corrections for quite some time; a correction would be healthy for this market. It would scare the masses and sentiment would turn negative again, setting the bedrock for the markets to rally higher.
Economic recovery is Illusory & So is the Current Fed Interest Rate Stance
The illusion that the economy is doing well is supported because of the vibrant stock market. The stock market appears healthy because hot money is driving it. If the supply of hot money is cut, the markets tank and the illusion that all is well will come to screeching halt. If this economy were healthy, the Fed would have raised interest rates several times over the past ten years and not just twice. Moreover, Yellen’s statement that we posted at the onset of this article clearly indicates she is hedging her bets.
In the interim bullish sentiment has surged significantly on a percentage basis, and Bonds are trading in the extremely oversold ranges. The ingredients are in place for a decent correction. Don’t confuse the subsequent correction for a crash; the naysayers will do their best to have you believe that the world is going to end. We base our analysis on our Mass Sentiment indicators and the Trend indicator. When the trend turns negative, we will stop viewing substantial pullbacks as buying opportunities.
Change of Heart, March 2020
As we stated all along the Current Fed Interest Rate stance was nothing but B.S. They lowered rates by 50 basis points and flooded the system with liquidity. All it took was a simple coronavirus attack to be blown out of proportion. The tactic worked as the masses panicked and this allows the Fed to push as much money into the system as they want, without being questioned.
The Federal Reserve announced an emergency rate cut Tuesday of half a percentage point in response to the growing economic threat from the novel coronavirus. cnbc.com
They are also flooding the system with massive amounts of cash as noted below:
The Federal Reserve today announced that it will launch a series of massive cash injections into funding markets and begin buying longer-term government bonds as panic over the coronavirus pandemic increasingly stresses the nation’s financial system.
The announcement that more than $1.5 trillion will be pumped into the banking system over the next two days comes as the Treasury market has shown signs of strain. Interest rates on U.S. government debt recently plunged to record lows, as investors poured money into safe assets, but now trading in that market is not flowing smoothly. Politico
Stock market outlook March 12, 2020
This pullback has been so sharp that its virtually going to re-energize this bull and Dow 39K could now become a possibility. Sounds insane, well that is exactly what our prediction for Dow 30K looked like when the Dow was trading below 21K, and it came to pass as the Dow came within striking zone of that target
Our anxiety gauge has now dipped into the madness zone, something it has never done before and if it remains here when our indicators pullback into the oversold ranges on the weekly chart, it could trigger the “father of all buy” signals
V readings as per our V-Indicator (the image on the top right of the market update) has surged 650 points to an all-time new high of 8000. Its most substantial one-week move, both in terms of percentage and points, since the inception of this indicator. The trend is positive, so when the markets reverse the reversal is likely to be very strong and catch many players off guard
Bearish sentiment has soared
The first thing that stands out is the bearish sentiment has shot to a new 52-week high and likely a multi-year high. But more importantly, Neutral sentiment has dipped below 20, indicating that individuals left this camp in mass, believing that this is the end of the bull and the world. This is fantastic news from a long term perspective as it has just injected several more years of life into this bull.
Bearish sentiment is also at a multi-year high, another bullish development. The most exciting development is that the gauge on the anxiety index is trading in a zone it has never traded before. If it remains at this level or moves deeper when our indicators on the weekly charts are trading in the oversold to extremely oversold ranges, it will trigger the father of buy signals.
Based on history, this bull market is not dead, it has taken a severe blow, but people will look back 3 and 6 months from now with surprise and 12-24 months with pure shock as they beat themselves for having allowed a fantastic opportunity escape them.
He that’s secure is not safe. Benjamin Franklin
Other Stories of Interest
Trading The Markets & Investor Sentiment (March 3)
Stock Market Bull 2019 & Forever QE (June 13)