Mass psychology and investing

Mass Psychology & Financial Success: An Overlooked Connection

Introduction to Mass Psychology

An Introduction to Mass Psychology: Understanding Group Behavior?

Mass psychology is a branch of social psychology that focuses on the study of group behaviour and the emotions, beliefs, and attitudes that drive the behaviour of large groups of individuals. It aims to understand why people behave the way they do in a group setting, and how the opinions, beliefs, and emotions of others influence this behaviour. Mass psychology is relevant in many fields, including marketing, politics, and finance, as it helps explain why people make certain decisions, why trends emerge, and why certain events occur. It is an important tool for anyone looking to understand the behaviour of large groups and to make informed decisions, whether in business, investing, or everyday life

Defining Mass Psychology from a Contrarian Perspective:

Defying the Crowd: Exploring the Underbelly of Mass Psychology! This thought-provoking study goes against the grain of conventional wisdom, delving into the darker side of group behaviour and decision-making. From exploring why people follow the masses blindly to the dangers of conformist thinking, it uncovers the driving forces behind herd mentality, revealing how to use this knowledge to your advantage and make bold, contrarian moves in the face of popular opinion. A must-read for anyone seeking a contrarian edge in life and business.

Mass Psychology: A Contrarian View

 To be wise is to be open, to be open is to be knowledgeable; to be knowledgeable is to understand that you really know nothing. Sol Palha

Mass psychology, the emotional and behavioural influence of a group of individuals on one another, is a timeless phenomenon that has only recently come to light. From flocks of birds to shoals of fish, it’s evident in nature that creatures tend to follow a leader. Yet, contrary to popular belief, evidence suggests that humans are not always rational in their decision-making, as emotions, biases, and cultural influences often override rational thought. This leads to the formation of herding behaviour, which has far-reaching implications in fields such as investing. For the contrarian investor, understanding the principles of mass psychology and how to think independently from the crowd is essential in making well-informed decisions. For a more comprehensive look at the subject, consider reading the entire How to use Mob psychology to invest in the markets

Mass Psychology and Market Success: Staying Ahead of the Crowd

Mass Psychology and Stock Markets

Mass psychology may have its roots in the emotional and behavioural influence of the herd, but the savvy contrarian investor knows better. The masses may follow the crowd like a flock of sheep, but true success in investing lies in marching to the beat of your own drum. So, when the Market is awash with pessimism, and the streets resemble a scene from a horror movie, it’s time to buy low with a smile and a twinkle in your eye. And when the masses are so caught up in their excitement that they’re doing the investing equivalent of a conga line, it’s time to sell high, tip your hat, and bid them adieu. Remember, the only thing more beautiful than making a profit is making it while thumbing your nose at conventional wisdom.

The astute investor purchases when the crowd panics and sells when the mob is jumping up with joy.

The Mass Mindset: Key Concepts and Applications in Mass Psychology

Going against the grain has never been more crucial in the world of investing. Research and data-driven analysis reveal the significance of mass psychology in the realm of investing. The masses may follow each other like lemmings, but astute contrarian investors know that true financial success lies in taking a different approach. By studying and understanding the masses’ behavioural patterns and emotional drivers, they can identify when to make a bold, counterintuitive move informed by research and data.

The dot.com boom of the late 1990s serves as a case study of the dangers of blindly following the herd without proper analysis. True leaders in the stock market are not afraid to chart their course, swim against the tide, and leverage research and analysis to inform their decisions. So, be an astute investor, embrace your inner contrarian, and lead the pack to financial success by relying on research and data-driven analysis. So, be a contrarian, blaze your own trail, and reap the rewards of thinking outside the box.

The Role of Mass Psychology in Making Sound Investment DecisionsAnxious Investor

Contrarian investing at its finest is about swimming against the tide and bucking the trend of conventional wisdom. The astute and contrarian investor had the foresight to see the limitless potential of the Internet, despite the scepticism and lack of interest from the masses. By recognizing the paradigm-shifting potential of this new technology and the dynamics of mass psychology, they were able to make bold and strategic investments.

The result? They reaped the rewards of their informed and counterintuitive approach, swimming against the tide and beating the market. The Internet revolution showed that the key to financial success in investing is a combination of research, analysis, and a willingness to challenge conventional wisdom and take a contrarian stance. In adopting this stance, these investors not only beat the market but also rewrote the rules of investing and proved that being a contrarian can lead to immense financial success.

Article of Interest: Mass Hysteria Equates To Stock Market Opportunity

The Crowd Mentality: Why Group Thinking Can Be Dangerous

The masses’ negative perception of a particular sector provides a prime opportunity for the astute and contrarian investor to act. Such was the case with the Internet sector in the 1990s. The foresighted investor opened positions in this sector while the masses were still sceptical and took a wait-and-see approach. By the time the masses finally jumped on the bandwagon in mid to late 1998, the astute investor had already established a strong position. The subsequent market frenzy and eventual sector implosion serve as a reminder that following the crowd and herd mentality can lead to devastating losses, while a contrarian approach can lead to substantial rewards. The Internet sector provides a vivid example of the power of a contrarian and informed investment strategy.”

 

Navigating Groupthink: The Role of Mass Psychology in Investment Decision

follow the leaders

The leaders were alarmed at this behaviour, as they should have been since this frenzy was not sustainable. History clearly indicates that the masses have never been on the right side of the markets going back all the way to the Tulip Mania.  One can clearly see how the big players employ mass Psychology to  fleece the masses; the topic is dealt with very succinctly in this article; Psychological & Economic Deception Wall Street’s Weapon of Choice

Back to the dot.com bubble; knowing that the end was near, they started to sell towards the end of 1999 and move their assets into cash and bonds, while the feeding frenzy continued. In March 2000, the markets began to correct, and by the end of the year the primary uptrend line was violated, and the market was ready to crash. By 2002, the market had lost more than 70% of its value and many of the masses who had momentarily tasted wealth moved to a state of poverty that they could not have envisioned a few months back.

Article of Interest: Hysteria Definition Equals Overreaction To The Coronavirus

 

Exploring the Essential Principles of Mass Formation Psychology

Mass Psychology Key Principles

 

  •  The leaders represent less than 2% of the population yet take in more than 90% of the profits.
  • When something is popular, the end is very near. One needs to do the opposite of what one’s emotions dictate when it comes to the markets.
  •  When an investment is viewed with disdain or frowned upon, then the time to open a position is close at hand.
  •  You have to learn how to fight the fear of selling out too fast after taking a position, remember it won’t just go up. Most likely it could even go down a bit more or move sideways for months or even a year. The one area you can draw comfort from is this, the longer the sideways action, the stronger the upward move will be when it finally transpires.

Other factors to consider in Mass Psychology

  •  Keep extra money on hand so that you can open additional positions at better if the opportunity arises
  •  In all likelihood you will have a 50-100% retrenchment in the first stage of the bull market, meaning that your shares could double and then shed a significant portion of the gains.  This is known as the shakeout phase, whereby the weak hands are forced out of their positions and end up selling at or very close to the bottom.  Holding on to the position usually, leads to huge rewards.
  •  When the investment become popular with the masses, pay close attention to market sentiment.   Perform simple trend line analysis on all your holdings.  Once the primary uptrend shows signs of wear, start banking your profits and tighten your stops.
  •  Wait patiently for the next opportunity to show up; there is always another chance.

Article of Interest: Trading The Markets & Investor Sentiment 

 

Improve Risk to Reward Ratio: Combine Mass Psychology with Technical Analysis

Technical Analysis Plus Mass Psychology

Mass psychology is not a complex field; in fact, it is very easy to understand; all one needs is a bit of common sense

Once you understand the basics,  it becomes easy to see why the masses are on the wrong side of the market.  When one combines Crowd Psychology with Technical Analysis, the risk-to-reward ratio improves significantly. This combination provides one with the opportunity to consistently be on the right side of the market.

 

The Big Picture: Important Considerations for Understanding Mass Psychology

Stock Market Identification

Mass Psychology comes to identifying the emotion that is driving the markets. Once you identify the emotion, it is very easy to spot a new trend. Now that you know the basics of Mass psychology you might also find the contrarian investing topic to be of interest. One key factor that is important to all stock market traders and investors, is portfolio management.

Article of Interest: Volatility Index Readings & Stock Market Trends

The Trend is your friend  

Mass Psychology the trend is your friend

 

There is no tool more powerful than Crowd Psychology.  It is the crowd that drives the market and the driving force behind the masses is emotions.  Therefore it is imperative that you understand what emotions are driving the masses at any given moment in time. Understand the emotion, and you know the market.  Only then should one look into trying to master technical analysis. Fundamental analysis is fundamentally flawed as the data is provided in a standard format. This means that anyone looking at the data will arrive at the same conclusion.

In an extensive reading of recent books by psychologists, psychoanalysts, psychiatrists, and inspirational lists, I have discovered that they all suffer from one or more of these expression-complexes: italicizing, capitalizing, exclamation-pointing, multiple-interrogating, and itemising. These are all forms of what the psychos themselves would call, if they faced their condition frankly, Rhetorical-Over-Compensation. James Thurber 1894-1961

Understanding psychology is key to becoming a better investor. If you understand the emotion driving the market, you will be light years ahead of the competition.

Random Musings On Crowds

The masses are unaware that everything is manipulated; from the food, you eat to the information you are provided. Hence they cannot come up with a plan. 80% of the work involved in finding a workable solution is to identify the problem correctly.   The mass media and the top players understand that if they alter your perception, they can control your actions. In other words, if the angle of observance is altered so is your perception. If you understand this simple principle, then you will be in control of your perceptions. 

Most experts focus on the tree or the forest; in both instances, they fail to see the big picture. This is why most experts are on par with rubbish- a smelly substance that has a strong effect but produces nothing of value.  We firmly suggest that you read or view  Plato’s allegory of the cave.   It will open your eyes to the basic concepts of Mass Psychology and why so-called experts are almost always wrong.

Knowledgeable Experts on  the subject of Mass Psychology

Knowledgeable Experts on  the subject of Mass Psychology

“It is crowds rather than isolated individuals that may be induced to run the risk of death to secure the triumph of a creed or an idea, that may be fired with enthusiasm for glory and honour… Such heroism is without doubt somewhat unconscious, but it is of such heroism that history is made.”

“He is no longer himself, but has become an automaton who has ceased to be guided by his will.”

“In a crowd every sentiment and act is contagious, and contagious to such a degree that an individual readily sacrifices his personal interest to the collective interest.”

“Ideas being only accessible to crowds after having assumed a very simple shape must often undergo the most thoroughgoing transformations to become popular. It is especially when we are dealing with somewhat lofty philosophical or scientific ideas that we see how far-reaching are the modifications they require in order to lower them to the level of the intelligence of crowds…. However great or true an idea may have been to begin with, it is deprived of almost all that which constituted its elevation and its greatness by the mere fact that it has come within the intellectual range of crowds and exerts an influence upon them.”

“The majority of men, especially among the masses, do not possess clear and reasoned ideas on any subject whatever outside their own specialty. The leader serves them as guide.”

“How numerous are the crowds that have heroically faced death for beliefs, ideas, and phrases that they scarcely understood!”

“Were it possible to induce the masses to adopt atheism, disbelief would exhibit all the intolerant ardour of a religious sentiment, and in its exterior forms would soon become a cult.

“In crowds the foolish, ignorant, and envious persons are freed from the sense of their insignificance and powerlessness, and are possessed instead by the notion of brutal and temporary but immense strength.

”consciously on men’s minds is the only real tyranny, because it cannot be fought against.”(The Crowd: A Study of the Popular Mind – Gustave Le Bon)

Quotes from Michael Montaigne

Mr Montaigne was a very wise man and the quotes listed below provide a window into the inner workings of the mass mindset and can be used to improve one’s understanding of Mass Psychology

Ignorance is the softest pillow on which a man can rest his head.

Rejoice in the things that are present; all else is beyond thee. Michel de Montaigne

A wise man never loses anything, if he has himself. Michel de Montaigne

The most certain sign of wisdom is cheerfulness. Michel de Montaigne

In true education, anything that comes to our hand is as good as a book: the prank of a page- boy, the blunder of a servant, a bit of table talk – they are all part of the curriculum. Michel de Montaigne

Age imprints more wrinkles in the mind than it does on the face. Michel de Montaigne

Carl Jung on Crowds

“…if people crowd together and form a mob, then the dynamisms of the collective man are let loose – beasts or demons that lie dormant in every person until he is part of a mob. Man in the mass sinks unconsciously to an inferior moral and intellectual level, to that level which is always there, below the threshold of consciousness, ready to break forth as soon as it is activated by the formation of a mass.”

“The bigger the crowd, the more negligible the individual.”

“A group experience takes place on a lower level of consciousness than the experience of an individual. This is due to the fact that, when many people gather together to share one common emotion, the total psyche emerging from the group is below the level of the individual psyche. If it is a very large group, the collective psyche will be more like the psyche of an animal, which is the reason why the ethical attitude of large organizations is always doubtful. The psychology of a large crowd inevitably sinks to the level of mob psychology. If, therefore, I have a so-called collective experience as a member of a group, it takes place on a lower level of consciousness than if I had the experience by myself alone.”

Other Articles of Interest

financial anxiety

Financial anxiety: Follow The Trend

Financial anxiety: Short-term market outlook Feb 2, 2023 The following projections were curated from the November 28th Market Update, providing ...
Read More
Investment Opportunity & Market Crashes

Investment Opportunity & Trading in the zone

Trading in the Zone: Mastering the Psychology of Trading Dec 30, 2022  Irrefutable Evidence that Crashes Equate to Investment opportunity: ...
Read More
worst 25 year period in stocks

Worst 25 year period in stocks?

Is It The Worst 25-year period in stocks? Dec 2022 No, it's not the worst 25-year period in stocks; it's ...
Read More
Copper outlook

Copper outlook VIA CPER

Copper outlook: To dance or Not to Updated March 2023 In the August 27 market update on the copper outlook: ...
Read More
Broad Market

Market Sentiment Analysis: Broad Market Review

Market Sentiment Analysis: Buy The Fear Updated Feb 2023 One has to understand the difference between the forest (broad market ...
Read More
existing home sales

Existing home sales

Nov 28, 2022 One can see that while the median price has been rising, new existing home sales have been ...
Read More
stock market crashes in history

Stock Market Crashes in History

Oct 3, 2022 A study of the stock market crashes in history reveals one upbeat fact; the ones that lost ...
Read More
stock market crash history

Market Crash History: The 1970s Era

Sep 26, 2022 An examination of any  Market crash history reveals one stunning fact. Investors that jumped in and bought when ...
Read More
Russia Update on Ruble Neon Gas and more

Russian Update: Ruble, Neon Gas and more

Russian Update 1: World's Top Performing Currency? The Russian Ruble, now the strongest currency in the World, has been trading ...
Read More
stock market rally

Stock Market Rally: Reality or Illusion?

Summer Stock market rally: To be or not to be? We expected the markets to correct last year, but it ...
Read More
Intelligent Investing Strategies

Intelligent Investing: Harnessing the Power of Data-Driven Approaches

Intelligent Investing: Navigating the Stock Market with Confidence To win, you have to have a stake in the market; it ...
Read More
trading volatility

Trading volatility: A whole New Stock Market Game

Trading volatility: Stick With The Trend Updated Dec 2022 Volatility will keep rising as we are in the battle of ...
Read More
stock market crash 2022

Stock Market Crash 2022

Stock market crash 2022: Reason No. 1 Updated Dec 2022 In addition to the many reasons we have provided in ...
Read More
Trading Journal

Trading Journal: The invaluable tool for traders

Trading Journal Nov 19, 2022 We will start by listing a series of quotes from recent market updates. If you ...
Read More
Trending markets

Market Trend Analysis: Only The Trend is your friend

Market Trend Analysis Updated July 2022  Trending markets currently favour value stocks and growth stocks that took a beating in ...
Read More
Stock market experts

Stock market experts know Nothing

 o Stock market experts focus on fiction, not facts Updated Dec 2022 Last week’s bullish readings dropped to 22, and ...
Read More
stock market technical analysis

Stock market technical analysis

Stock market technical analysis on its own produces mediocre results. However, when combined with Mass psychology the results are outstanding ...
Read More
market tops

Market Sentiment Made Easy: Sell Euphoria and Reap Rewards

Market Sentiment: Euphoria Equates To Market Tops Updated Feb 2023 Even though things are viewed as bad now, these times ...
Read More
lot size

Tactical Investor Lot Size

This was initially posted in the Market Update forum. The current version is being modified to reflect a potential change ...
Read More
Panic Buying

Panic Buying Equates to Fools Paradise

Panic Buying & Losses: Best bed Partners Updated Dec 2022  Panic buying can be contrasted with panic selling, in which ...
Read More
panic selling

Panic Selling: Buy The Fear & Sell The Joy

Many subscribers (mistakenly) assumed that we were stating that the markets were ready to Drop. And they started to close ...
Read More

References

Sir John Templeton’s Template for success, Templeton.org, https://www.templeton.org/about/sir-john

Five pieces of advice from John Bogle, NY Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/17/business/mutfund/john-bogle-vanguard-investment-advice.html

The armchair millionaire, Lewis Schiff, https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/236260.The_Armchair_Millionaire

Etraodinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds, Charley Mackay, https://www.gutenberg.org/files/24518/24518-h/24518-h.htm

Study Shows The Power Of Social Influence: 5 Ways To Avoid The Herd Mentality, Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/amymorin/2014/07/25/study-shows-the-power-of-social-influence-5-ways-to-avoid-the-herd-mentality/#799020bb6e4e

Herd mentality: Are we programmed to make bad decisions?, Science Daily, https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/12/141216212049.htm

Mob Mentality: The Madness of the Crowd, Brain World, https://brainworldmagazine.com/mob-mentality-the-madness-of-the-crowd/

Propaganda and Indoctrination, Noam Chomsky, https://chomsky.info/20001210/

The Crowd, A Study of the Popular Mind: Gustave Le Bon, http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/445

Five warning signs of market euphoria, Investopedia, https://cutt.ly/rslGnYU

Impact of Mass Media Use on Youth. NCBI Resources, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2792691/

Homerun definition, The free dictionary, https://financial-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/home+run

The pros and cons of mass media, Waldern University, https://bit.ly/2Egoq65

Why people lose money in the markets, The Balance,  https://cutt.ly/rslG1eK

Prepare for massive stock market opportunities, Market Watch, https://on.mktw.net/32QvqB4

What is mass hysteria, Medical News Today,  https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/322607

Any Monkey can beat the Market, Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/rickferri/2012/12/20/any-monkey-can-beat-the-market/

Random Walk Down Wall Street, Burton Malkiel, https://cutt.ly/5slKVMl

How a cat & some Monkeys Outperformed experts, The Fool, https://bit.ly/2ZYQljy

Russian Chimpanzee outperforms 94% of Bankers, Dailymail.co.uk, https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1242575/Lusha-monkey-outperforms-94-Russia-bankers-investment-portfolio.html

 

1 comment

Trend Following Jay

Thanks for the great blog post!

I’ve actually created a similar article about ‘7 Trading Psychology Ideas from Dr. Brett Steenbarger.

I think you’ll love it and it’d be beneficial to your followers, as well.

Here’s the link if you’d like to take a look:
http://www.intelligenttrendfollower.com/trading-psychology-brett-steenbarger/

Jay