Trading Clarifications

a_p
blue pill or red pill
blue pill or red pill
Posts: 18
Joined: Tue Nov 10, 2020 4:20 am

Re: Trading Clarifications

Post by a_p »

So, part of an answer to my question about end of day stops has been provided in latest market update, and it was embedded in a description of one of the plays.

Why couldn't this information be provided here in the forum, or (better yet!) in much-suggested reading materials? I guess we'll never know :lol:
For new subscribers, this is why an end of day stop is superior to traditional stops. Most of our stocks trend higher after the stop is triggered. An end day stop (which is a mental stop), is triggered when the stock closes at or below the suggested stop price. After that, one places a GTC limit sell order, and there is no need to flee for the exits, as the majority of the plays we have been stopped out of trended higher. Thus, investors can usually get a better price, as was the case with CCMP.
It still doesn't elaborate what is typically done in cases when it *doesn't* trend higher, as is mostly the case during a strong pullback, like in spring 2020, where a lot of stocks didn't recover to their proposed stop for a very long time.
User avatar
AstuteShift
Black Belt
Black Belt
Posts: 1083
Joined: Thu Oct 01, 2020 11:24 pm

Re: Trading Clarifications

Post by AstuteShift »

a_p wrote: Sat Feb 20, 2021 11:08 pm So, part of an answer to my question about end of day stops has been provided in latest market update, and it was embedded in a description of one of the plays.

Why couldn't this information be provided here in the forum, or (better yet!) in much-suggested reading materials? I guess we'll never know :lol:
For new subscribers, this is why an end of day stop is superior to traditional stops. Most of our stocks trend higher after the stop is triggered. An end day stop (which is a mental stop), is triggered when the stock closes at or below the suggested stop price. After that, one places a GTC limit sell order, and there is no need to flee for the exits, as the majority of the plays we have been stopped out of trended higher. Thus, investors can usually get a better price, as was the case with CCMP.
It still doesn't elaborate what is typically done in cases when it *doesn't* trend higher, as is mostly the case during a strong pullback, like in spring 2020, where a lot of stocks didn't recover to their proposed stop for a very long time.
If you mean long time as in the span of a couple of months then it’s really nothing.

The real meat of the service is the trend indicator which has been on the point for a very long time. The stocks SOL picks also are a big winners

The results of me and other members confirm this.

When the markets are in disarray you always want to be buying. It’s extremely simple and not complicated unless you succumb to fear.

The other factor is just waiting and relaxing. The top players always have initial paper losses at first but they don’t care since their investments will reap big profits later on. Also they divide their money in lots and don’t time tops or bottoms

Buy into fear and panic and sell when the masses are singing heaven. Winning formula and easy to implement once false filters are removed
User avatar
George1010
The Journey begins
The Journey begins
Posts: 94
Joined: Mon Oct 12, 2020 5:07 am

Re: Trading Clarifications

Post by George1010 »

a_p wrote: Sat Feb 20, 2021 11:08 pm So, part of an answer to my question about end of day stops has been provided in latest market update, and it was embedded in a description of one of the plays.

Why couldn't this information be provided here in the forum, or (better yet!) in much-suggested reading materials? I guess we'll never know :lol:
For new subscribers, this is why an end of day stop is superior to traditional stops. Most of our stocks trend higher after the stop is triggered. An end day stop (which is a mental stop), is triggered when the stock closes at or below the suggested stop price. After that, one places a GTC limit sell order, and there is no need to flee for the exits, as the majority of the plays we have been stopped out of trended higher. Thus, investors can usually get a better price, as was the case with CCMP.
It still doesn't elaborate what is typically done in cases when it *doesn't* trend higher, as is mostly the case during a strong pullback, like in spring 2020, where a lot of stocks didn't recover to their proposed stop for a very long time.

End of day stops are covered well enough in the suggested reading material

All stops are now “end of day stops”; the stop is only triggered if the stock closes at or below the suggested price of the stop. For more details on “end of day stops” visit this link Detailed Info on Stops
I had no problem understanding the above statement. The stock closes at or below the suggested stop price and tomorrow as a trader you try to get the possible price. I did not even click on the link that provides more details. If the stock continues to trend down which has not happened to me yet, I would just get out at the best possible price. In the AI service, what happened is one stock gapped down and opened the next day below the stop price. The stop price was 18, I got out at 14 or better and that was it. However, I closed the first half for a profit of almost 90% and even though I was stopped out at 14.00 I still got out above the entry price of 12 and change. The reason I got out at 14 or better is I decided to have no stop in place. When I saw the stock Gap down I decided it was time to get out, so I adjusted the rules.


If you click on the link suggested this is what it says on End of day stops https://tacticalinvestor.com/what-is-a-limit-order/
What is an “end of day stop”?
It’s like a mental stop as you don’t enter any trade in your brokerage account until the stock closes at or below the stated stop price. In the case of IBB, the stop is 81.00. IBB would have to close at 81.00 or below for the stop to be triggered. Then the next day you would enter a limit order (under order type select limit) to sell IBB at 81.00.
Logic dictates that just as Sol offers a range of entry points to go long, that if you can't get out at the suggested price you aim for the best possible price. Sol's team then uses this data to come out with an average exit price.

While I understand the need to get detailed info, the focus should not be on factors that are not maybe such a big issue and that we can work out ourselvesm. As Astute mentioned the power of this service, is the trend indicator, the sentiment data and the incredible Stock picks. Getting stopped out once in a while in comparison is not a big issue, even if I might have to get out a price that is lower than the suggested stop price.

There is no way to come out with an idiot's guide to investing; it's an impossible feat. The TI Teams sends out a lot of past updates, several years worth to be precise, I think dating all the way back to 2015. If you go through those updates you can see that very often he discusses adapting the service to suit your needs. For example. I sometimes use end of day stops, sometimes I use a regular stop and sometimes I use no stops.

This is just my two cents and not an attack on your question.


But in this day and age where it is hard to find a good service, it is a breath of fresh air to find a service that offers a massive bang for the buck and where Sol and his team go out of their way to help investors develop some form of independence. The sheer volume of good reading material is also something you would be hard-pressed to find anywhere.


Be patient and things will start to make sense. Read as many past updates as you can and if you have the time read as many of the articles posted on the site that you can. Each article and each past issue I read helped me make better sense of the service. The articles on stock market crashes are quite good
User avatar
AstuteShift
Black Belt
Black Belt
Posts: 1083
Joined: Thu Oct 01, 2020 11:24 pm

Re: Trading Clarifications

Post by AstuteShift »

The service is extremely powerful and yes it’s simple.

However, it does take time to fully implement or even understand what SOL does.

It took me several months to a year, since I was stuck in the fear loop.

Despite knowing options and trading like a market maker style it means nothing compared to trend analysis

Modifying the service to your needs is how I broke out of the fear cycle. I was like why not? Then I was impressed, however the MP talk did shook my core and being. In some ways, I was even angry at first, then realized, accepted it then started to study/understand it

Then I saw the beauty how MP really works, also the wonderful books that help one to awaken instead of being a sheep

You start to evolve and even apply it to your real life as well. No other service comes close
a_p
blue pill or red pill
blue pill or red pill
Posts: 18
Joined: Tue Nov 10, 2020 4:20 am

Re: Trading Clarifications

Post by a_p »

George1010 wrote: Sun Feb 21, 2021 5:38 am There is no way to come out with an idiot's guide to investing; it's an impossible feat. The TI Teams sends out a lot of past updates, several years worth to be precise, I think dating all the way back to 2015. If you go through those updates you can see that very often he discusses adapting the service to suit your needs. For example. I sometimes use end of day stops, sometimes I use a regular stop and sometimes I use no stops.

This is just my two cents and not an attack on your question.
You clearly made no attempt to understand what I was saying in my last post, nor my original one, nor anything else I wrote.
I had a simple question, and it had a simple answer. But, of course, it is much better to keep chanting the same tangential mantra about how great the service is (which I preemptively and explicitly tried not to call into question), and call a person an idiot in a non-attacking way.
Nice going, my man. I think I should say no more.
User avatar
AstuteShift
Black Belt
Black Belt
Posts: 1083
Joined: Thu Oct 01, 2020 11:24 pm

Re: Trading Clarifications

Post by AstuteShift »

a_p wrote: Mon Feb 22, 2021 12:20 am
George1010 wrote: Sun Feb 21, 2021 5:38 am There is no way to come out with an idiot's guide to investing; it's an impossible feat. The TI Teams sends out a lot of past updates, several years worth to be precise, I think dating all the way back to 2015. If you go through those updates you can see that very often he discusses adapting the service to suit your needs. For example. I sometimes use end of day stops, sometimes I use a regular stop and sometimes I use no stops.

This is just my two cents and not an attack on your question.
You clearly made no attempt to understand what I was saying in my last post, nor my original one, nor anything else I wrote.
I had a simple question, and it had a simple answer. But, of course, it is much better to keep chanting the same tangential mantra about how great the service is (which I preemptively and explicitly tried not to call into question), and call a person an idiot in a non-attacking way.
Nice going, my man. I think I should say no more.
Looking back at the old updates, TI did very well. Buying google, pjt and a host of other stocks went to rally pretty well.

With all the information and guidance, SOL can’t hold your hand every minute of every waking day or through each trade

If you rely on one person too much then the real you will disappear and you will end up being a glorified blind man, as SOL states

Consider TI a partnership and a very good one. However as a trader you have the final say and how you operate your business of trading
User avatar
SOL
Power VS Force
Power VS Force
Posts: 3267
Joined: Sat Sep 26, 2020 7:32 am

Re: Trading Clarifications

Post by SOL »

a_p wrote: Mon Feb 22, 2021 12:20 am
George1010 wrote: Sun Feb 21, 2021 5:38 am There is no way to come out with an idiot's guide to investing; it's an impossible feat. The TI Teams sends out a lot of past updates, several years worth to be precise, I think dating all the way back to 2015. If you go through those updates you can see that very often he discusses adapting the service to suit your needs. For example. I sometimes use end of day stops, sometimes I use a regular stop and sometimes I use no stops.

This is just my two cents and not an attack on your question.
You clearly made no attempt to understand what I was saying in my last post, nor my original one, nor anything else I wrote.
I had a simple question, and it had a simple answer. But, of course, it is much better to keep chanting the same tangential mantra about how great the service is (which I preemptively and explicitly tried not to call into question), and call a person an idiot in a non-attacking way.
Nice going, my man. I think I should say no more.
let's attempt to defuse the situation. The simplest way to fix a problem is not to argue about it :)

Okay putting myself in your shoes and viewing the situation as a brand new subscriber. I can see where you might run into some issues. What we can do is put more info on why end of day stops are used, if necessary more information on how to implement them and lastly what to do in the event that the stock drifts lower. Would that help.?

Secondly, while we speak of timing market tops and bottoms, there is a vast difference between that and trying to time the exact top. For example, stating that the housing market is going to top and we did that before the markets melted down in 2009, but we were off by 1 year. Our goal was not to time the exact top but to get out of the sector because the situation became too hot.

When Bitcoin hit 20k and people started making claims that it could trade to 1 million, we stated it was time to get out. Bitcoin did not top the next day, it took some time but then Bitcoin dropped all the way to the 3K ranges.

So when we talk about market tops and market bottoms we are not talking about timing the actual event or stating that when it hits so and so price the market is going to TANK ASAP.
When the words short term appear under any post; the same conditions listed in the Market update under the short term category apply

The end is always near; its the beginning and how you live each moment that counts the most
a_p
blue pill or red pill
blue pill or red pill
Posts: 18
Joined: Tue Nov 10, 2020 4:20 am

Re: Trading Clarifications

Post by a_p »

SOL wrote: Mon Feb 22, 2021 7:17 am Okay putting myself in your shoes and viewing the situation as a brand new subscriber. I can see where you might run into some issues. What we can do is put more info on why end of day stops are used, if necessary more information on how to implement them and lastly what to do in the event that the stock drifts lower. Would that help.?
Sounds perfectly reasonable.
extra123
blue pill or red pill
blue pill or red pill
Posts: 22
Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2021 9:43 pm

Re: Trading Clarifications

Post by extra123 »

SOL wrote: Wed Feb 17, 2021 1:56 am
qfactors wrote: Tue Feb 16, 2021 8:15 pm
I will admit that I am the odd one out :shock: . When I first subscribed to SOL in Jan 2020, I asked for past updates to Jan 2018. I had tracked all his Trend Portfolio trades (not the Moderate and ETFs). I also did not track options since I do not use options. I scaled in in 3 parts and scaled out in 2 parts as suggested. I bought at the top, and sold at the bottom of his recommended range so I was taking the worst possible performance case.

For the period from Jan 2020 to last week, the SP500 was about 47%. The Trend portfolio was 102%.

I did the same for the AI portfolio. For the period from Jun 2020 to last week, the SP500 was 29%. The AI portfolio was 75%. The gift from SIEB was an incredible boost.

I can produce performance charts of these two portfolios vs the SP500, but I an still a noob at how to post pictures :lol:

Hope this help.
We created this article especially for you, it will walk you through the process of posting images on this forum. It is really simple and once you get the hang of it, you will be posting images on the fly. Click on this link https://tacticalinvestor.com/phpbb-forum/
SIEB up 90% after hours on earnings. Though I was fortunate enough to sell when it exploded a few months ago because of the reddit craze, in hindsight wondering if we should have bought it again when it went back to the low 4's like our first entry point. We live and learn.
User avatar
SOL
Power VS Force
Power VS Force
Posts: 3267
Joined: Sat Sep 26, 2020 7:32 am

Re: Trading Clarifications

Post by SOL »

a_p wrote: Tue Feb 23, 2021 10:34 am
SOL wrote: Mon Feb 22, 2021 7:17 am Okay putting myself in your shoes and viewing the situation as a brand new subscriber. I can see where you might run into some issues. What we can do is put more info on why end of day stops are used, if necessary more information on how to implement them and lastly what to do in the event that the stock drifts lower. Would that help.?
Sounds perfectly reasonable.
It's been done, let me know if that's good enough?
When the words short term appear under any post; the same conditions listed in the Market update under the short term category apply

The end is always near; its the beginning and how you live each moment that counts the most
User avatar
hooligan
Junior
Junior
Posts: 142
Joined: Fri Oct 09, 2020 12:48 am

Re: Trading Clarifications

Post by hooligan »

While we're at this, I'd love to ask some questions about the charts in Market Update.

First I'd like to say that I respect whatever Sol wants to keep to himself. I have no desire to come off greedy for info or ungrateful for the service. With that said, here are some questions and comments:

-On the most recent market update, all the charts are in July. Just sayin.

-What are the two indicators below each chart? One green and one blue/red.

-What are the trend lines? A specific indicator or just hand-placed?
Post Reply